Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Insurance Executive Sues Law Firm Over Lost £4.5m Tui Claim

📅 2026-11-13 | 📰 Insurance Business UK
#professional indemnity #slater and gordon #personal injury #litigation risk #tui uk

Claire Saywell, an insurance executive from Sittingbourne, Kent, is suing law firm Slater and Gordon UK for £4.5m after a procedural error led to her personal injury claim against Tui UK being struck out. The legal firm has admitted that it failed to validly serve the claim form, which was sent to the incorrect email address.

The original claim stemmed from a 2017 incident at the four-star Club Hotel Dolphin in Waikkal, Sri Lanka. On February 16, 2017, Saywell was sunbathing when a coconut palm tree fell onto her lounger. The impact bent her legs backward at the knee, resulting in emergency surgery in Colombo and approximately 10 subsequent operations. Saywell, who previously worked as a commercial insurance broker and peripatetic insurance executive, is now unemployed and requires single-storey accommodation due to ongoing pain and disability.

The legal dispute now centers on the value of the lost claim, which Master John Dagnall has categorized as a “loss of a chance” case. Under this legal framework, the court must assess the likelihood of success the original claim against Tui would have had. Saywell’s legal team argues that the claim had a greater than 90% chance of success, citing an arborist’s report suggesting the tree had been compromised by a utility line anchor, making it susceptible to falling even in light winds. Four witnesses were prepared to testify that wind conditions on the day were modest.

Slater and Gordon contests the £4.5m valuation, arguing that the original case against Tui did not exceed a 51% likelihood of success. The firm maintains that the incident was caused by a sudden, strong gust of wind—a natural event—rather than negligence by the hotel or its contractors. Master Dagnall has granted Saywell permission to rely on the arborist’s evidence, and both parties are now pursuing alternative dispute resolution.

The error in this case was administrative rather than a failure of legal strategy, highlighting the persistent risk of procedural lapses in legal practice. For professional indemnity insurers, this case underscores the financial exposure associated with high-value claims that exceed primary layer coverage, particularly when administrative oversight leads to the loss of a client's right to pursue litigation.

Why it matters

This case serves as a stark reminder for PI insurers of the significant financial exposure posed by administrative errors in high-value litigation, which can easily exceed primary indemnity layers.

FAQ

Why was the original claim against Tui struck out?
Slater and Gordon failed to validly serve the claim form because it was sent to the wrong email address.

What is the core disagreement between the plaintiff and the law firm?
The parties disagree on the value of the lost claim, specifically the likelihood of success the original case against Tui would have had, with the plaintiff claiming over 90% and the defense arguing for 51%.

What is the basis for the claim that the tree was dangerous?
An arborist reported that a spike and concrete had been driven into the base of the tree to anchor a utility line, which caused rot and damage to the trunk.

Source: Insurance Business UK. See the original source for full details.