Roof Age Data Accuracy Critical for Property Renewals
Insurers are increasingly scrutinizing roof construction details, including material types and installation dates, as severe convective storm and hail losses continue to impact property underwriting. According to Kimberly Roberts, head of North America peril advisory at Marsh Re, carriers are moving away from relying solely on self-reported data. Instead, underwriters are prioritizing high-quality data and may require site inspections to verify the physical condition of properties, particularly in areas with significant catastrophe exposure.
The pressure on carriers is driven by recurring losses throughout storm seasons. While Moodyโs recorded 3,706 US hail reports in the first half of 2026โa decrease from the 7,290 reports during the same period in 2025โGallagher Re still ranked the first half of 2026 as the seventh on record for insured severe convective storm losses. These losses, which include tornadoes and straight-line winds, are increasingly being absorbed by insurers due to higher reinsurance retentions that have been in place for the last three to four years.
Financial impacts are significant. State Farm reported paying over $5.6 billion in US hail-related claims in 2025, with $1.4 billion of that total attributed to Texas. Furthermore, Verisk noted that the average residential roof replacement cost reached $17,631 in 2025, marking a 33% increase from the 2021-2024 average. These rising costs, combined with the potential for insurers to switch to actual cash value settlements as roofs age, make accurate documentation essential.
For brokers, managing these renewals requires precise record-keeping. A partial roof replacement, if not clearly documented, can complicate the underwriting process. Brokers are advised to use dated contractor invoices, permit records, and clear documentation of which roof sections were covered by specific repairs to provide a complete picture for underwriters. In cases where records are incomplete, brokers should proactively ask underwriters what evidence is acceptable or if a site inspection is necessary. Additionally, brokers should verify that renewal documents correctly reflect the age of the roof and clarify specific wind and hail deductibles for clients.
Regulatory environments are also evolving. In Texas, the Department of Insurance has proposed clarifying a rule that prevents insurers from declining or refusing to renew coverage based strictly on roof age, though insurers may still consider the roof's physical condition. The department also advises homeowners to review their wind and hail deductibles, which may differ from other policy deductibles.
Why it matters
As reinsurance retentions rise and convective storm losses persist, underwriters are demanding granular roof data, making accurate documentation essential for brokers to secure favorable renewal terms for their clients.
FAQ
How many US hail reports were recorded in the first half of 2026 compared to 2025?
There were 3,706 US hail reports in the first half of 2026, down from 7,290 in the same period in 2025.
What is the average residential roof replacement cost as of 2025?
Verisk reported the average residential roof replacement cost was $17,631 in 2025, a 33% increase from the 2021-24 average.
What regulatory proposal regarding roof age is being considered in Texas?
The Texas Department of Insurance has proposed clarifying a rule that bars homeowners insurers from declining or refusing to renew coverage based solely on roof age, while still allowing consideration of the roof's physical condition.
Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone