Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Insurers Struggle to Address AI Risks in Cyber Policies

📅 2026-11-13 | 📰 Insurance Journal
#cyber insurance #artificial intelligence #ai risk #policy exclusions #underwriting

The rapid integration of artificial intelligence into business operations has created a significant challenge for the cyber insurance market. While McKinsey & Company reports that 88% of organizations now regularly use AI in at least one business function, the insurance sector has struggled to adapt its underwriting and risk models to this technological shift. This hesitation has led many carriers to adopt strategies that prioritize risk avoidance, often at the expense of policyholder security.

Data indicates a growing disconnect between corporate risk perception and insurance coverage. Nearly 83% of S&P 500 companies have identified AI as a material risk, and 87% of executives view AI-related vulnerabilities as the fastest-growing cyber threat. Despite this, over 60 property and casualty insurance groups have filed to implement AI exclusions within their policies. These filings signal industry anxiety, even though AI has become a fundamental component of the modern business software stack.

Carriers are generally employing two problematic tactics: blanket exclusions or policy silence. Broad exclusions allow insurers to potentially challenge or deny claims simply because an AI tool was involved, even if the primary cause of the loss was human error—a factor traditionally covered by cyber insurance. Alternatively, some insurers remain silent on AI in their policy language. This ambiguity creates significant uncertainty, forcing businesses to navigate potential legal battles to determine if their coverage applies to AI-driven security failures or privacy breaches.

Experts argue that the industry is treating AI as an unquantifiable threat rather than an evolution of existing risks. Many AI-enhanced incidents, such as business email compromise, are familiar threats that have been managed for years. For instance, business email compromise remains the most common event type, accounting for 31% of all claims in 2025. While AI allows bad actors to hyper-personalize messages or use deepfakes for fraud, the underlying business impact—such as funds transfer fraud—remains consistent with historical risks.

Rather than defaulting to exclusions or silence, the industry is encouraged to develop affirmative policy language that clarifies how coverage responds to AI-driven threats. Defenders are already utilizing AI through managed detection and response (MDR) platforms to triage threats in milliseconds, proving that the technology can be a tool for protection as well as a vector for attack. Carriers possess the data and underwriting capabilities to accurately price these risks, and a failure to evolve policy language risks leaving policyholders with dangerous coverage gaps.

Why it matters

The insurance industry's current uncertainty regarding AI coverage creates significant liability gaps for businesses, necessitating a shift toward clearer, affirmative policy language to maintain market relevance.

FAQ

How many P/C insurance groups have filed to adopt AI exclusions?
More than 60 property and casualty insurance groups have filed to adopt AI exclusions.

What percentage of claims in 2025 were attributed to business email compromise?
Business email compromise represented 31% of all claims in 2025.

What are the two primary tactics insurers are using to manage AI risk?
Insurers are primarily using either blanket AI exclusions or remaining silent on AI in their policy language.

Source: Insurance Journal. See the original source for full details.