Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Health Insurers Owe $460M in 2024 MLR Rebates

๐Ÿ“… 2026-11-16 | ๐Ÿ“ฐ Insurance Business America
#mlr rebates #unitedhealth group #health insurance #cms data #medical loss ratio

Health insurers reported $460 million in federal medical loss ratio (MLR) rebates for the 2024 reporting year across small and large group markets, according to an analysis of data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). The total includes $274 million in the small group market and $185.9 million in the large group market.

UnitedHealth Group recorded the largest rebate obligations in both categories. The insurer owed $94.2 million in the small group market across 29 state filings and $98 million in the large group market across 27 state filings. Elevance Health followed as the second-largest payer in the small group market at $77.3 million, while Independence Blue Cross Group ranked second in the large group market at $20.6 million.

The data, compiled by benefits proposal software company Planlined, highlights geographic disparities. Massachusetts led the small group market with $54.4 million in rebates, while Pennsylvania topped the large group market at $27.1 million. Conversely, several states and territories, including Alaska, North Dakota, and West Virginia, reported no rebates in either market.

MLR rebates are triggered when a carrierโ€™s three-year pooled loss ratio in a specific state and market falls below the required standardโ€”80% for small group plans and 85% for large group plans. These figures reflect the insurer's entire book of business within that jurisdiction rather than the claims experience of any single employer. It is important to note that these regulations apply exclusively to fully insured arrangements; self-funded and level-funded plans are exempt from MLR reporting and rebate requirements.

For industry professionals, these rebate figures serve as a critical data point during renewal negotiations. When carriers propose rate increases for upcoming plan years while simultaneously owing rebates due to failing to meet loss ratio standards, the discrepancy provides necessary context for brokers and employers. As margin compression continues to drive more mid-market employers to consider self-funded alternatives, these MLR filings offer a transparent look at carrier performance that should be integrated into the broader renewal conversation.

Why it matters

MLR rebate data provides brokers and employers with essential transparency regarding carrier performance, which can be a valuable leverage point during renewal discussions and rate negotiations.

FAQ

What is the difference between small and large group MLR standards?
Small group plans must meet an 80% loss ratio standard, while large group plans must meet an 85% standard.

Do self-funded plans owe MLR rebates?
No, MLR rules apply only to fully insured arrangements, meaning self-funded and most level-funded plans do not file MLR reports or owe rebates.

Why does the rebate data vary by state?
Rebates are based on a carrier's pooled three-year loss ratio within a specific state and market, which varies depending on the insurer's performance in that region.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.