Texas Court Upholds Negligence Verdict Against Nursing Home
A Texas appeals court has affirmed a negligence verdict against Red Bluff LLC, a nursing home operator, regarding a 2016 workplace injury. The case, Red Bluff LLC v. Nicole Tarpley, centered on an incident at the company’s Pasadena, Texas, facility where a certified nursing assistant sustained knee, neck, and back injuries while transferring a patient weighing over 300 pounds.
The injury occurred when the patient’s wheelchair brakes disengaged, causing the patient to fall onto the employee. Testimony revealed that while the facility’s standard protocol required at least two staff members for such a transfer, the employee was instructed to perform the task alone. Furthermore, evidence indicated the employee received only one day of floor orientation, despite the facility’s three-day standard. Because Red Bluff LLC opted out of the Texas workers compensation system, it faced a negligence lawsuit with limited legal defenses.
A jury originally awarded the plaintiff $7.11 million in damages, covering physical impairment and future medical costs. While the 14th District Court of Appeals upheld the negligence finding and the physical impairment awards, it determined there was insufficient evidence to support the full $500,000 in future medical expenses. Consequently, the court ordered a reduction of $264,448.51, adjusting the future medical portion to $235,551.49. The plaintiff has 20 days to accept this reduction, or the case will be remanded for a new trial.
For insurers and risk managers, this case underscores the significant liability exposure faced by non-subscribers in the Texas workers compensation market, where the absence of statutory immunity allows for substantial negligence claims and jury-awarded damages.
Why it matters
This case highlights the financial and legal risks for employers who opt out of workers compensation insurance in Texas, as they lose key defenses against negligence lawsuits.
FAQ
Why was Red Bluff LLC sued for negligence?
The nursing home operator opted out of the Texas workers compensation system, which allows injured employees to sue for negligence with limited legal defenses.
What caused the injury to the nursing assistant?
The employee was injured while transferring a patient weighing over 300 pounds when the wheelchair brakes disengaged, causing the patient to fall on her.
Did the appeals court change the original damage award?
Yes, the court reduced the future medical expenses portion of the award by $264,448.51, citing insufficient evidence for the original amount.
Source: Business Insurance. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone