Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Soft Market Risks: High-Risk Trades and Inadequate Cover

📅 2026-11-11 | 📰 Insurance Business UK
#insurance #high-risk trades #underwriting #construction insurance #soft market

Recent government initiatives aimed at curbing rogue building practices, including an Approved Code for home improvement traders and a Trusted Payments system, have sparked discussions about whether insurance requirements could eventually become a prerequisite for securing contracts. However, industry experts warn that current market conditions may allow high-risk trades to obtain insurance policies that do not adequately reflect their actual operational exposures.

Glenn Marshall, managing director and chief underwriting officer at Gem Underwriting, notes that it is currently too easy for contractors to secure competitive insurance quotes without undergoing sufficient scrutiny regarding their experience, working practices, or safety standards. Misrepresentations on proposal forms often remain undetected until a claim is filed. Marshall identifies high-risk construction trades—specifically roofing, scaffolding, demolition, asbestos, and waste-related activities—as having the highest potential for severe injury or fire-related claims.

The competitive landscape for these sectors is significantly tighter than for lower-risk trades like plumbing or painting, with only about 15 markets available for high-risk coverage compared to roughly 30 for others. While competition has increased over the last 12 to 18 months, underwriting remains selective. Marshall suggests that in a soft market, brokers may approach multiple insurers and receive quotes without being asked detailed questions. This creates a scenario where a client secures a price that suits their budget, but the policy may contain critical gaps, such as height restrictions that do not align with the contractor's actual work.

The reliance on automated rating engines and portals further complicates risk assessment. While these tools offer efficiency, they may fail to capture the full scope of a contractor's exposure. A small scaffolding firm, for example, might receive an instant quote based on minimal data, leading to years of renewed coverage that remains untested until a significant claim arises. Although insurers rarely pursue policyholders for repayment after paying out claims despite policy breaches, such recovery efforts are often futile if the business has become insolvent.

True risk assessment requires deeper due diligence, including credit checks, reviews of liquidation history, and checking for Health and Safety Executive prohibition notices. During harder market cycles, only contractors with robust safety records and established insurer relationships could secure affordable coverage. Currently, however, commercial pressures in a soft market may disincentivize such thorough screening. Even if a contractor produces a certificate showing £10m in public liability cover, it does not guarantee the policy is tailored to the specific work being performed.

Why it matters

The current soft market environment may mask significant coverage gaps for high-risk contractors, potentially leaving insurers exposed to unexpected liabilities when policy conditions are tested by claims.

FAQ

Which construction trades does Gem Underwriting classify as high-risk?
High-risk trades include roofing, scaffolding, demolition, asbestos, and waste-related activities.

Why is it difficult for insurers to recover costs from policyholders after a breach?
While policy terms may allow insurers to seek repayment, recovery is often impossible if the contractor's business has become insolvent.

What is the primary danger of using automated rating systems for high-risk trades?
These systems may provide instant quotes based on limited data, failing to establish the full exposure or specific risks associated with the contractor's work.

Source: Insurance Business UK. See the original source for full details.