Retirement Plan Design Boosts Savings for Inactive Employees
A retrospective analysis from Voya Financial’s Behavioral Finance Institute for Innovation reveals that retirement plan design significantly influences savings outcomes, particularly for participants who do not engage with their accounts. The study, which reviewed 310,931 participants across 877 plans between December 2017 and June 2026, found that savings rates for individuals who never logged in, read projections, or adjusted contributions improved four times more in plans with behavioral design features compared to traditional plans.
The research defines behaviorally informed plans as those utilizing automatic enrollment and automatic escalation. Participants in these plans saw an average savings rate improvement of 3.33 percentage points, while those in traditional plans saw a 1.64-point increase. Plans incorporating both automatic enrollment and automatic escalation yielded the highest results, with a 3.56-point improvement. For non-digitally engaged participants specifically, the difference was stark: those in plans with both automatic features saw savings rates improve by 4.09 points, compared to just 0.99 points for similar participants in traditional plans.
While plan design drives progress for inactive users, digital engagement also grew during the study period, rising from 57.5% of participants in 2017 to 76.1% in 2026. Digitally engaged participants in behaviorally informed plans achieved average savings rates exceeding 11% of pay by 2026 and experienced a 234% growth in account balances, compared to 201% for engaged participants in traditional plans. Voya noted that market returns contributed to these balance growth figures.
Despite these outcomes, adoption of these features remains limited. According to Gallagher’s 2026 US Benefits Strategy and Benchmarking Survey of 3,717 organizations, only 57% of employers use auto-enrollment and 33% use auto-escalation. Meanwhile, only 28% of employees believe their current strategy will secure their retirement. Tom Armstrong, vice president of customer analytics at Voya, stated that individuals should not need to focus on retirement daily to make progress. As SECURE 2.0 mandates automatic enrollment for most new plans, sponsors are increasingly evaluating starting contribution rates, as Vanguard’s 2026 data shows 38% of auto-enrollment plans set initial contributions below 4%.
For insurers and plan sponsors, this data underscores the potential for plan architecture to bridge the gap between employee access and financial outcomes, suggesting that default settings may be as critical to long-term success as participant education.
Why it matters
This data highlights how default plan features like auto-enrollment and auto-escalation can drive participant savings outcomes even when employees remain disengaged.
FAQ
How much did savings rates improve for non-engaged participants in plans with automatic features?
Non-digitally engaged participants in plans with both automatic enrollment and automatic escalation saw their savings rates improve by 4.09 percentage points.
What percentage of employers currently use auto-enrollment and auto-escalation?
According to Gallagher’s 2026 US Benefits Strategy and Benchmarking Survey, 57% of employers use auto-enrollment and 33% use auto-escalation.
Did market returns impact the account balance growth mentioned in the study?
Yes, Voya noted that market returns contributed to account balance growth for both digitally engaged groups, so those figures should not be viewed as solely a result of plan design.
Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone