Retailers Revise Safety Plans Amid Expanding Violence Risks
Retailers are re-evaluating insurance coverage and emergency response protocols as the scope of workplace violence widens and some insurers tighten assault and battery exclusions. The shift is prompting a review of safety measures alongside new regulatory demands, notably New York’s Retail Worker Safety Act, which from Jan. 1, 2027 will require large retailers with 500 or more employees to install silent emergency response buttons for staff to summon security or managers during incidents.
The New York mandate builds on earlier provisions of the act that, by June 2025, required all retailers with ten or more employees to adopt workplace violence prevention policies and provide related training. Historically, retailer training focused on robberies, shoplifting apprehensions and active assailant scenarios, according to David Johnston, vice president of asset protection and retail operations at the National Retail Federation. Over the past several years, however, retailers report a broader array of violent encounters, including disputes over store policies, refunds, and increased shoplifting-related aggression.
A recent National Retail Federation survey indicated that a notable share of retailers observed a rise in guest-related violence, while another segment reported more incidents tied to criminal activity such as shoplifting. The report also highlighted that demonstrations, civil unrest and domestic disputes can spill into retail environments, further expanding the risk landscape.
Coverage options for these incidents may be found in general and excess liability policies or in specialized workplace violence insurance. Workers’ compensation typically covers physical injuries, but state statutes differ on coverage for mental injuries resulting from violence. Some insurers are now excluding assault and battery coverage from general liability policies or applying sublimits, noted Chip Stuart of Hub International. As a result, retailers may need to purchase separate assault and battery coverage from specialty carriers, which can increase costs.
Insurers also factor crime scores into risk assessments, influencing premiums based on store locations. Retailers are checking whether they have adequate strikes, riots and civil commotion coverage, according to Peter Bransden of Willis Towers Watson. While some property insurers had previously limited or excluded SRCC coverage after the 2020 George Floyd protests, much of that capacity has returned. Use of embedded or standalone active assailant and workplace violence coverage has grown over the past five years, reflecting an expectation that retailers adopt proactive risk-mitigation strategies rather than rely solely on indemnity products.
Active assailant and workplace violence policies can provide direct access to crisis-response specialists and victim support services, helping protect retailer reputations after an incident, said Gabriella Cserei of WTW’s Alert 24 service. These policies often include risk-mitigation allowances that encourage proactive steps to reduce threats before they materialize.
Violence-related workers’ compensation claims represent about one percent of total claims among Gallagher Bassett’s retail clients, according to Jennifer Kastenholz of the firm. While overall claim frequency has declined due to safety initiatives, automation and store-layout changes, violence-related claims have declined more slowly and now represent a larger share of the remaining claims. Such claims cost roughly 40 % more on average than other claims, driven by lost work time and higher attorney involvement.
Why it matters
Retail insurers and risk managers must adapt policies and pricing to address expanding violence risks and new regulatory requirements.
FAQ
What new safety requirement will affect large New York retailers in 2027?
Retailers with 500 or more employees must provide silent emergency response buttons for staff to request immediate assistance.
How are insurers changing coverage for workplace violence?
Some insurers are excluding assault and battery coverage from general liability policies or imposing sublimits, prompting retailers to seek separate specialty coverage.
What impact do violence-related workers’ compensation claims have on costs?
These claims cost about 40 % more on average than other claims, due to lost work time and higher rates of attorney representation.
Source: Business Insurance. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone