Understanding the Drivers of Employer Health Care Costs
For many American employers, the annual health insurance renewal process is a recurring cycle of rising premiums attributed to vague factors like "claims experience" or "trend." While employers bear the financial responsibility for these costs, the structure of the current health care system often leaves them with little control over the variables driving those expenses.
A primary factor influencing these costs is the medical loss ratio (MLR) mandated by the Affordable Care Act. For groups with more than 50 employees, insurers are required to spend at least 85% of premiums on medical claims and quality improvement, leaving 15% for administrative costs and profit. Because this profit is calculated as a percentage of premiums rather than a fixed dollar amount, insurers can see their allowable profit increase as health care spending rises. This dynamic has encouraged vertical integration, with major insurers acquiring pharmacy benefit managers, physician groups, and outpatient facilities, creating enterprises that may benefit financially when health care costs grow.
The role of the insurance broker also plays a significant part in the cost landscape. Many brokers operate on a commission-based model, where compensation is calculated as a percentage of the total premium. Consequently, when premiums increase, broker compensation often rises as well. While many brokers prioritize client service, this traditional structure does not inherently align with an employer's goal of reducing costs, as moving a client to a lower-cost plan can result in lower pay for the broker. Although some are shifting toward fee-based, transparent models, the commission-based structure remains prevalent.
Health care providers operate within a dominant fee-for-service model, which prioritizes the volume of services delivered—such as visits, tests, and prescriptions—over the reduction of services. Because there is no built-in mechanism to reward providers for keeping a workforce healthier and utilizing fewer services, the system incentivizes higher activity. Furthermore, employers on fully insured plans often lack visibility into these costs. Insurer-negotiated rates with hospitals and physician groups are typically proprietary, leaving employers responsible for premiums without access to detailed claims data or insight into whether lower-cost alternatives were available.
For insurance professionals and employers, this landscape underscores the importance of scrutinizing compensation structures and data access. Understanding whether broker fees are tied to premium volume or if an employer has access to claims data can be critical for those seeking to move beyond passive acceptance of annual premium hikes.
Why it matters
This analysis highlights how structural incentives within the insurance and health care industries can conflict with an employer's goal of controlling rising health care costs.
FAQ
How does the Affordable Care Act's medical loss ratio affect insurer profits?
The rule requires insurers to spend at least 85% of premiums on claims and quality improvement, with 15% for admin and profit. Because profit is a percentage of premiums, allowable profit can rise as health care spending increases.
Why might broker compensation models conflict with an employer's cost-reduction goals?
Traditional broker compensation is commission-based, calculated as a percentage of the premium. Therefore, when premiums increase, the broker's compensation often increases, potentially disincentivizing a move to a lower-cost plan.
What is the primary challenge for employers on fully insured plans regarding provider costs?
Employers on fully insured plans often lack visibility into provider costs because insurer-negotiated rates are treated as proprietary, and these employers typically cannot access detailed claims data, especially if they have fewer than 100 enrolled employees.
Source: Business Insurance. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone