Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurementsCooking

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

West Virginia Court Voids Milbank UIM Policy Restriction

📅 2026-11-17 | 📰 Insurance Business America
#west virginia #uim #milbank insurance #supreme court #underinsured motorist

The West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals has ruled against Milbank Insurance Company, determining that a policy clause requiring a vehicle to be involved in an accident to qualify for underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage is unenforceable. The November 13, 2026, decision effectively voids the insurer's restrictive endorsement, which the court found conflicted with state statute.

The legal dispute originated from a fatal 2019 wrong-way collision on Ohio State Route 7. Caleb Ratcliffe, driving a Hyundai Accent owned by Sierra Mattson, collided head-on with another vehicle. Both Ratcliffe and Mattson were among the five individuals who died in the crash. Following the incident, the estate of the deceased passenger sought UIM benefits under Mattson’s Milbank policy. The estate argued that Ratcliffe’s own vehicle—which was parked at his home and uninvolved in the accident—qualified as an underinsured motor vehicle because the liability insurance associated with it was insufficient to cover the damages.

While the estate had already collected $120,000 from pooled liability proceeds from policies held by both Ratcliffe and Mattson, they contended this amount was inadequate. Milbank denied the UIM claim, citing a policy endorsement that required the underinsured vehicle to be involved in the accident for coverage to apply. The insurer argued that the liability must arise from the ownership or use of that specific vehicle.

The Circuit Court of Ohio County initially sided with the estate, but the Intermediate Court of Appeals later reversed that decision, favoring Milbank’s policy language. The Supreme Court of Appeals ultimately reinstated the original ruling, holding that the Milbank endorsement was more restrictive than the state’s UIM statute. The court emphasized that West Virginia law defines an underinsured motor vehicle based on the existence of applicable liability insurance, not the vehicle's physical presence at the scene. Furthermore, the majority noted that UIM coverage must be interpreted liberally to ensure full compensation for injured parties.

Chief Justice Bunn and Justice Trump dissented from the majority opinion. The case has been remanded to the lower court to address remaining claims, including allegations that Milbank’s UIM selection forms were defective. If proven, these defects could potentially raise the available coverage to the liability limits, rather than the policy's stated $25,000/$50,000 UIM limits. Other outstanding issues, such as bad faith and unfair settlement practice claims, also remain unresolved.

For insurers operating in West Virginia, this decision serves as a clear signal that policy endorsements attempting to limit UIM triggers to vehicle involvement will not withstand judicial scrutiny. Claims departments should re-evaluate existing UIM policy language to ensure compliance with the state’s liberal interpretation of coverage requirements.

Why it matters

This ruling limits the ability of insurers in West Virginia to restrict UIM coverage based on a vehicle's involvement in an accident, potentially increasing exposure for carriers.

FAQ

What was the core issue in the Milbank Insurance Company case?
The court decided whether a policyholder could claim UIM benefits using an uninvolved, parked vehicle as the 'underinsured' vehicle.

What did the West Virginia Supreme Court decide?
The court ruled that Milbank's policy endorsement requiring a vehicle's involvement in an accident to trigger UIM coverage was unenforceable and more restrictive than state law.

What happens next in the legal proceedings?
The case has been remanded to the lower court to address remaining claims, including allegations of defective UIM selection forms and bad faith.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.