Appeals Court Rejects Long COVID Workers' Comp Claim
A New York appellate court has ruled against a registered nurse seeking workers' compensation for long COVID symptoms, determining that the claimant failed to prove a causal link between her condition and an initial workplace infection. Susan Hahnenfeld, employed at Good Samaritan Hospital, contracted COVID-19 in April 2020. While she initially received workers' compensation benefits for that infection, her attempt to amend the claim to include long COVID was ultimately rejected.
Although a workers' compensation law judge initially amended the claim to include long COVID, the Workers’ Compensation Board reversed this decision in May 2025 due to a lack of sufficient evidence. The court noted that while Hahnenfeld’s neurologist diagnosed her with long COVID following reports of tremors, fatigue, and mobility issues, her medical history included hypertension, cancer, and an autoimmune disorder. Furthermore, she contracted COVID-19 again in December 2021. Because other physicians attributed her symptoms to preexisting musculoskeletal conditions or inflammation, the court upheld the board's decision, noting that the necessary causal connection was not established.
This ruling underscores the high evidentiary burden required to link ongoing health issues to workplace-acquired illnesses, particularly when claimants have complex pre-existing medical histories.
Why it matters
This case highlights the ongoing challenges insurers and boards face in adjudicating long COVID claims when distinguishing between occupational exposure and pre-existing or subsequent health conditions.
FAQ
Why was the nurse's long COVID claim denied?
The Workers’ Compensation Board and the appeals court found insufficient evidence to establish a causal connection between her symptoms and the April 2020 workplace infection.
What other medical factors were considered in the case?
Medical records indicated the claimant had an autoimmune disorder, hypertension, cancer, and had contracted COVID-19 a second time in December 2021.
Can long COVID be compensable under an existing claim?
Yes, the court noted that long COVID symptoms may be compensable under an established COVID-19 claim without a separate amendment, provided the necessary causal relationship is proven.
Source: Business Insurance. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone