NI Holdings exits non-standard auto in Plains states
NI Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: NODK) confirmed a complete exit from the non-standard auto market in North Dakota, South Dakota and Nebraska after reporting a 100.2% decline in premiums for the segment in the third quarter of 2026. The Fargo-based insurer’s subsidiaries, Primero Insurance Company and Direct Auto Insurance Company, had already left the line in Illinois, Arizona and South Dakota, and the latest figures indicate the runoff is now essentially finished.
The departure occurs while the broader non-standard auto market is strengthening. An AM Best report released in November 2025 showed net underwriting income of $65 million in the first half of 2025, nearly four times the amount recorded a year earlier, and a combined ratio improvement to 96.6 from 98.0 in full-year 2024. According to David Blades of AM Best, higher premiums have helped insurers better offset claim costs.
NI Holdings’ own results reflected mixed trends. Private Passenger Auto premiums fell 8.4% in the quarter, driven by lower new business and renewals in South Dakota and Nebraska and rate cuts across the three states. In contrast, the Home and Farm segment grew 1.9% on renewal premiums and rate increases in North Dakota, while the All Other segment surged 50.6% due to assumed premiums from catastrophe reinsurance programs.
The carrier posted a combined ratio of 93.6% for the quarter, down from 109.1% a year earlier, and net income of $5.5 million versus a $1.7 million loss in Q3 2025. Gross premiums written slipped 7.2% to $54.3 million. The ratio improvement stemmed largely from favorable prior-year loss-reserve development in non-standard auto, offset by less favorable development a year earlier.
For brokers in the Plains states, the key question now is which carriers remain active in the non-standard auto space and what terms they will offer. The AM Best analysis noted that non-standard auto companies acquired by larger national carriers have benefited from spreading costs over a broader premium base—an advantage NI Holdings could not achieve at its size.
The exit also coincides with broader rate trends. COUNTRY Financial announced auto rate reductions in 11 states in June 2026, including a 3% cut in North Dakota, citing fewer accidents and lower claim costs. The Insurance Information Institute and Milliman forecast a full-year 2026 personal auto combined ratio of 95.5, indicating a softening rate cycle in standard personal auto as well.
Additional pressures on NI Holdings included higher losses in its Crop segment, linked to drought conditions that affected more than half of North Dakota by early August 2026. Despite these challenges, the company’s net investment income fell 10.7% to $2.7 million as proceeds from maturities and sales were used to fund operating cash needs tied to the non-standard auto runoff.
Why it matters
The loss of a regional carrier narrows market choice for brokers handling non-standard auto, potentially affecting pricing and capacity.
FAQ
Which states did NI Holdings exit the non-standard auto market in?
North Dakota, South Dakota and Nebraska.
What was the percentage change in NI Holdings' non-standard auto premiums in Q3 2026?
Premiums declined 100.2%.
How did NI Holdings' combined ratio change from the prior year?
It improved to 93.6% from 109.1% a year earlier.
What broader market trend did AM Best report for non-standard auto in early 2025?
Net underwriting income rose to $65 million and the combined ratio improved to 96.6.
Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone