Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Nationwide Punitive Damages Reversed in Washington Appeal

📅 2026-11-11 | 📰 Insurance Business America
#nationwide #bad faith #punitive damages #insurance litigation #washington appeals court

A Washington Court of Appeals, Division III, has issued a mixed ruling regarding a $103 million judgment against Nationwide Affinity Insurance Company of America. The November 10 decision reversed a $47 million punitive damages award and dismissed an insurance consumer protection claim, while simultaneously upholding findings that the insurer acted in bad faith and was negligent.

The legal dispute originated from an August 2017 auto accident in Alberta, Canada, involving a Washington policyholder who ran a stop sign and was struck by a semi-truck. The policyholder and her husband were seriously injured, and their three children were killed. Although Nationwide acknowledged the policyholder was at fault and that claims would exceed the $200,000 policy limit, the insurer declined to pay the family’s claims immediately. Nationwide cited concerns that settling with one claimant would terminate its duty to defend, potentially leaving the policyholder exposed to a separate claim from the truck driver.

By August 2019, the husband initiated a lawsuit against his wife for the injuries and deaths resulting from the accident. An arbitration process eventually resulted in a $17,123,927.71 award, which Nationwide paid. Subsequently, a trial jury found the insurer liable for negligence, bad faith, and violations of the Insurance Fair Conduct Act (IFCA) and the Consumer Protection Act, awarding $27,136,000 in compensatory damages and $47 million in punitive damages.

The appellate court’s reversal focused on two primary areas. Regarding the IFCA, the court determined that the statute applies to the denial of coverage or benefits, not the delay of payment. Because Nationwide had paid the amounts owed under the policy before the statutory notice was filed, the court ruled that disputes regarding the speed of payment to third-party claimants do not trigger rights under that law. Additionally, the court rejected the punitive damages award, noting that the evidence did not meet the required threshold of hatred or ill will, and further clarified that Washington law—which does not permit punitive damages—should apply rather than Ohio law.

The court’s ruling leaves intact $5 million for bad faith, $2 million for negligence, and shared economic damages. The case has been remanded to the lower court for a recalculation of attorney fees and a reconsideration of potential injunctive relief regarding Nationwide’s claims practices.

For insurance professionals, this case highlights the risks inherent in multi-claimant scenarios where an insurer's strategy to protect the insured from exposure can inadvertently create bad faith liability by forcing family members into adversarial litigation.

Why it matters

This ruling clarifies the boundary between payment delays and benefit denials, emphasizing that insurers must carefully balance policyholder protection strategies against the risk of bad faith claims when handling multi-claimant losses.

FAQ

What parts of the original $103 million judgment were upheld?
The court upheld findings of bad faith and negligence, which include $5 million for bad faith, $2 million for negligence, and shared economic damages.

Why did the appeals court reverse the punitive damages?
The court ruled that the evidence did not meet the necessary threshold of hatred, ill will, or knowing disregard of harm, and determined that Washington law, which does not allow punitive damages, should apply.

What was the basis for dismissing the insurance consumer protection claim?
The court determined that the Insurance Fair Conduct Act covers the denial of coverage or benefits, not the delay of payment to third-party claimants.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.