Miami Contractor Charged in $100K Workers' Comp Fraud Case
Israel Carballo, owner of the Miami-based Carballo Group LLC, has been arrested on charges of theft and workers’ compensation fraud. According to court records, Carballo was taken into custody on November 5, pleaded not guilty, and has since been released on bond.
An investigation by the Florida Department of Financial Services revealed that Carballo allegedly underreported his firm’s 2023 payroll by approximately $1 million. By claiming a minimal workforce, Carballo secured a workers’ compensation policy from NorGuard, a Berkshire Hathaway company, for an annual premium of roughly $9,300. However, investigators subpoenaed subcontractor records indicating the company had actually paid workers over $1,074,000. Affidavits suggest the true premium should have been $109,863, resulting in a loss of more than $100,000 for the insurer. The investigation also identified the use of check-cashing services, likely to facilitate cash payments to employees.
Florida state records indicate Carballo Group was registered in 2023 but was dissolved in 2025 for failing to file an annual report. Carballo has claimed indigent status in the ongoing legal proceedings.
This case underscores the persistent risk of premium fraud in the construction sector and highlights the importance of rigorous payroll audits for insurers underwriting high-risk commercial policies.
Why it matters
This incident highlights the financial risks insurers face from payroll manipulation and the necessity of verifying subcontractor data during the underwriting and audit processes.
FAQ
What specific charges does Israel Carballo face?
Carballo has been charged with theft and workers’ compensation fraud.
How much did the insurer lose in this alleged scheme?
The investigation suggests NorGuard Insurance was defrauded of more than $100,000 in premiums.
What was the actual payroll compared to what was reported?
Carballo reported a small number of workers for a $9,300 premium, but records showed actual worker payments of $1,074,000.
Source: Insurance Journal. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone