Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Maryland High Court Weighs Sovereign Immunity in Abuse Cases

📅 2026-11-11 | 📰 Insurance Journal
#maryland #sovereign immunity #child victims act #liability #lawsuits

The Supreme Court of Maryland is currently reviewing an appeal that centers on whether the state’s 2023 Child Victims Act effectively waived sovereign immunity for sexual abuse claims dating back to before 1982. The outcome of this legal challenge will specifically impact approximately 1,300 lawsuits filed under the act, representing about 11% of the 12,000 total cases initiated since the law’s passage.

The 2023 legislation removed time barriers for filing institutional sex abuse claims. However, the state argues that because it held absolute immunity from civil lawsuits prior to 1982, the legislature was required to expressly and unambiguously waive that protection. State attorneys have filed roughly 200 motions to dismiss these older cases. While some lower court judges have denied these motions, others in Frederick County and Baltimore City have already dismissed cases based on the sovereign immunity argument.

During oral arguments, attorneys for the plaintiffs contended that the legislature’s inclusion of damage caps in the 2023 law demonstrates a clear intent to accept liability, thereby implying a waiver of sovereign immunity. Conversely, the state’s legal team maintained that legislative intent cannot be assumed and that the absence of explicit language regarding the pre-1982 immunity means the protection remains in effect. Chief Justice Matthew Fader questioned whether the legislature was even aware of the immunity protections in place during that era when drafting the 2023 law.

The financial implications of the court's decision are substantial. The 2023 law capped damages against the state at $890,000 per occurrence, though the definition of an "occurrence" remains a point of contention. If the state is found liable for the pre-1982 cases, potential payouts could reach approximately $11 billion, depending on how occurrences are defined and whether settlements are reached. The Office of the Attorney General has noted that blocking these pre-1982 claims would reduce the state's potential liability by more than $1 billion.

Why it matters

The court's ruling on sovereign immunity will define the scope of state liability and potential financial exposure for thousands of historical abuse claims, which could influence future legislative drafting and risk management strategies.

FAQ

What is the core legal issue being debated?
The court is deciding if the 2023 Child Victims Act clearly and knowingly waived the state's absolute sovereign immunity that existed for lawsuits regarding sexual abuse occurring before 1982.

How many cases are affected by this specific appeal?
The appeal concerns approximately 1,300 lawsuits involving allegations that took place prior to July 1, 1982.

What is the potential financial impact on the state?
If the state is held liable for these cases, estimates suggest potential payouts could reach $11 billion, though settlements could reduce this figure.

Source: Insurance Journal. See the original source for full details.