Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Court Denies Restaurant Fire Claim Over Unattended Grill

📅 2026-11-13 | 📰 Insurance Business UK
#insurance claim #fire damage #insurance act 2015 #hospitality insurance #risk reduction

A Scottish court has ruled that Intact Insurance UK is not liable for a property damage and business interruption claim filed by P B Development Company Limited. The decision, issued by the Outer House of the Court of Session on November 11, 2026, centers on a breach of a kitchen equipment clause in the insurance policy for the Aberdeen restaurant Vovem Meat & Liquor.

The dispute arose following a fire at the restaurant in September 2024. The policy contained a specific provision requiring that cooking equipment must not be left unattended while the heat source is operating. The contract explicitly stated that failure to adhere to this condition would result in the insurer denying property damage or business interruption claims.

CCTV evidence presented to the court detailed the timeline of the incident. The ox grill was lit shortly after 11am on September 26, 2024. While staff were present in the building, the court found that the grill was left without proper supervision. Specifically, one staff member left the kitchen entirely for two minutes and 45 seconds. Other employees, including a duty manager and a prep chef, were in the vicinity but were not in a position to monitor the equipment as required.

By 11:32, embers were visible above the grill, and by 11:43, burning fat was falling from the extraction canopy. The kitchen was evacuated by 11:49. The restaurant operator argued that because staff were in the building, the grill was effectively attended. The court rejected this interpretation, drawing on a 1962 legal precedent regarding unattended property. The court determined that being in the vicinity is insufficient; an employee must be in a position to observe and intervene if necessary.

The restaurant also invoked Section 11(3) of the Insurance Act 2015, which prevents insurers from relying on a breach of a risk-reduction clause if the policyholder can prove the breach could not have increased the risk of the loss. The operator claimed the fire originated in concealed ductwork where grease had accumulated, meaning supervision of the grill would not have prevented the ignition.

The court disagreed, citing evidence that the fire began under the canopy before spreading into the ductwork. The ruling noted that had the grill been properly attended, staff likely would have detected the early stages of the fire and taken action to prevent its spread. This decision serves as one of the first substantive interpretations of Section 11(3) of the Insurance Act 2015.

Why it matters

This ruling provides a rare judicial interpretation of Section 11(3) of the Insurance Act 2015, clarifying how courts assess risk-reduction clauses and the potential for loss mitigation.

FAQ

Why was the insurance claim denied?
The court found the restaurant breached a policy condition requiring cooking equipment not to be left unattended while the heat source was operating.

What was the restaurant's argument regarding the Insurance Act 2015?
The restaurant argued that the breach did not increase the risk of loss because the fire started in concealed ductwork, but the court ruled that early intervention might have prevented the spread.

How did the court define 'unattended'?
The court ruled that being in the vicinity is not enough; staff must be in a position to observe the equipment and intervene if a problem arises.

Source: Insurance Business UK. See the original source for full details.