Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

LEG defect clauses updated after 27 years

📅 2026-11-10 | 📰 Insurance Business UK
#leg #defect clauses #car #ear #iua

The London Engineering Group (LEG) has issued three revised model defect exclusion clauses for contractors' all risks (CAR) and engineering all risks (EAR) policies, marking the first update since the original 1996 publication. The new wordings, designated with the suffix /26, replace the long-used /96 and /06 versions and were formally launched at Lloyd’s Old Library following LEG’s affiliation with the International Underwriting Association (IUA) in July.

The revision follows two US court decisions in 2023 and 2024 that described LEG 3 as “egregiously ambiguous” and “internally inconsistent,” finding the language failed to clearly exclude the claims before them. Those rulings prompted some insurers to withdraw LEG 3 from US construction risks and substitute “cost of making good” endorsements. Although the shock subsided and LEG 3/26 remained available for international risks in the London market, the cases highlighted the need for a wording review.

The three clauses now operate on a sliding scale. LEG 1/26 provides an absolute exclusion for damage caused by a defect. LEG 2/26 excludes the cost that would have been incurred to replace or rectify defective property had the defect been discovered before any damage occurred. LEG 3/26, which carries a higher premium and a narrower exclusion, removes only the additional cost of improving the material, workmanship, design, plan or specification used for the defective property. While the underlying intent of each clause is unchanged, LEG has published explanatory commentary alongside the new wordings for the first time, available through the IUA’s clauses database.

Charlie Dee, UK construction underwriting manager at Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance and chair of LEG, said the update results from extensive work and aims to keep the clauses relevant to today’s construction risk insurance. He expressed hope that the new clauses and commentary will give insurers, brokers and clients a clear and practical framework.

The US cases centered on the definition of “damage” versus “defect” and the meaning of “improvement” in LEG 3. In contrast, English law provides a clearer definition of damage, as affirmed by the Court of Appeal in the 2024 Sky UK Ltd and Mace Ltd v Riverstone Managing Agency Ltd decision, which held that damage requires an adverse physical change that impairs a property’s value or usefulness. Insurers have been granted leave to appeal that ruling to the Supreme Court, so the definition may be revisited.

Brokers handling CAR and EAR placements must note that policies written on the old /96 or /06 wording remain in force under those terms, while the /26 clauses apply only to new business. The language change will need to be explained to clients during renewals or coverage restructures. The IUA’s clauses database now offers a single access point for the new wordings and commentary, consolidating resources previously spread across LEG’s independent operations.

Why it matters

The updated clauses affect how insurers price and underwrite construction risks, and brokers must explain the new wording to clients.

FAQ

What are the new suffixes for the revised LEG defect clauses?
The revised clauses carry the suffix /26, replacing the previous /96 and /06 versions.

Why were the LEG clauses revised?
Two US court decisions in 2023 and 2024 found LEG 3 ambiguous and inconsistent, prompting a review of the wording.

What does LEG 3/26 exclude?
LEG 3/26 removes only the additional cost of improving the material, workmanship, design, plan or specification used for the defective property.

Where can the explanatory commentary for the new clauses be accessed?
The commentary is available through the IUA’s clauses database.

Source: Insurance Business UK. See the original source for full details.