Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Hartford Units Fail to Prove Harm After Late Asbestos Notice

📅 2026-11-06 | 📰 Business Insurance
#hartford #asbestos coverage #late notice #new jersey law #appeals court

The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia reversed a lower-court ruling that favored three Hartford insurance units—First State Insurance Co., Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co., and Hartford Fire Insurance Co.—in a coverage dispute stemming from a $70.1 million mesothelioma verdict. The case, GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. v. First State Insurance Company, involved GEA of Janesville, Wisconsin, which sued the insurers a day after notifying them of the verdict in August 2019, nearly two months after the jury award.

Under New Jersey law, an insurer must demonstrate both a breach of notice terms and a “likelihood of appreciable prejudice” to deny coverage for late notice. The appeals court held that Hartford failed to meet this burden, noting that conjecture or suspicion cannot establish prejudice. Hartford’s witness described how the claim would have been assessed but did not specify any settlement offer or action that would have produced a better outcome, and the court rejected an affidavit from the Thorntons’ lawyer as inadmissible hearsay.

The district court, on remand, again ruled for the insurers, reasoning that Hartford’s asbestos-outcome databases could have helped secure a better settlement. The appellate panel disagreed, emphasizing that the insurer must show a concrete likelihood of a superior settlement, not merely speculation. The decision vacated the lower-court ruling and sent the case back for further proceedings. The ruling applies only to The Hartford; other defendants such as Wellfleet New York Insurance and Continental Insurance were not addressed.

Why it matters

The decision clarifies the evidentiary standard insurers must meet to deny coverage for delayed notice, affecting how asbestos claims are handled.

FAQ

What was the amount of the asbestos verdict in the case?
A jury awarded $70.1 million in the mesothelioma suit.

When did GEA notify Hartford of the verdict?
GEA notified Hartford in August 2019, nearly two months after the verdict.

What legal standard must insurers meet to deny coverage for late notice in New Jersey?
Insurers must show a breach of notice terms and a likelihood of appreciable prejudice.

Which insurers were involved in the appellate ruling?
First State Insurance Co., Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co., and Hartford Fire Insurance Co.

Source: Business Insurance. See the original source for full details.