Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurementsCooking

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

ACE Denies Coverage for eBay's $55.7M Harassment Settlement

📅 2026-11-17 | 📰 Insurance Journal
#ebay #insurance coverage #ace property & casualty #settlement #harassment

ACE Property & Casualty Insurance Co. has filed a legal action in federal court in California, seeking a declaration that it is not obligated to indemnify eBay for a $55.7 million settlement. The settlement resolved a civil lawsuit brought by a Massachusetts couple, Ina and David Steiner, who were the targets of a harassment and stalking campaign orchestrated by former eBay executives and employees.

The insurer argues that the losses associated with the settlement are not covered under its excess commercial umbrella policy. ACE contends that the actions taken against the Steiners were expected or intended by the insured, and therefore fall outside the scope of coverage. The policy specifically excludes coverage for bodily injury or property damage that is expected or intended from the standpoint of the insured. Additionally, the policy excludes personal injury coverage if the insured knew the act would violate the rights of another, inflict injury, or if the injury arose from a criminal act.

ACE further asserts that eBay breached its insurance contract by settling the lawsuit without the insurer's consent. The insurer claims it was not provided with necessary information to evaluate the settlement and notes that the agreement failed to allocate damages between compensatory and punitive categories. Citing California law, ACE emphasizes that it is prohibited from insuring losses that result from an insured party's deliberate misconduct.

The harassment campaign, which occurred in 2018 and 2019, involved members of eBay’s security team and senior management. The Steiners, publishers of the trade publication EcommerceBytes, were subjected to threatening messages, the delivery of menacing items such as live spiders and a bloody pig mask, and physical stalking. Seven members of eBay’s security team eventually pleaded guilty to federal crimes related to these activities. eBay also entered into a deferred prosecution agreement with the U.S. Attorney’s Office, acknowledging responsibility for the acts of its employees and agreeing to pay a $3 million criminal penalty.

ACE maintains that the involvement of senior leadership, including the former CEO, indicates that these were not the actions of rogue managers but were directed by those controlling the company’s operations. The settlement, finalized in June 2026, included $48.7 million in compensation for the Steiners, with contributions from eBay and former executives, alongside $7 million in charitable donations.

This case highlights the critical intersection of corporate governance, criminal liability, and insurance indemnification, specifically regarding whether deliberate executive misconduct can be transferred to insurers. Risk managers and underwriters should monitor this litigation closely, as it underscores the limitations of excess commercial umbrella policies when faced with claims arising from intentional torts and criminal acts committed by senior leadership.

Why it matters

This case serves as a significant test of whether insurance policies can be triggered for settlements involving intentional, criminal misconduct by corporate leadership.

FAQ

Why is ACE Property & Casualty Insurance Co. refusing to cover the settlement?
ACE argues the acts were expected or intended by the insured, that eBay breached the contract by settling without consent, and that California law prohibits insuring losses from deliberate misconduct.

What specific exclusions are cited in the ACE policy?
The policy excludes bodily injury or property damage expected or intended by the insured, as well as personal injury caused by the insured with knowledge that the act would violate rights or inflict injury, or that arises from a criminal act.

How was the $55.7 million settlement distributed?
The Steiners received $48.7 million in compensation, with $46.15 million from eBay, $2 million from former CEO Devin Wenig, and $550,000 from two other executives. Additionally, $7 million was pledged to charitable organizations.

Source: Insurance Journal. See the original source for full details.