Jane Kim to Review California Insurance Reforms
Jane Kim has secured victory in the race for California insurance commissioner, defeating fellow Democrat Ben Allen with 54.2% of the vote. With her lead exceeding 900,000 votes, Kim is set to replace term-limited incumbent Ricardo Lara. A consumer advocate and attorney who served on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors from 2011 to 2019, Kim ran on a platform emphasizing insurance affordability, transparency, and expanded coverage.
Central to the transition is Kim’s plan to review the Sustainable Insurance Strategy implemented by Lara. This strategy, designed to encourage insurers to write homeowners policies in wildfire-distressed areas, allows carriers to utilize reinsurance costs and catastrophe models in ratemaking while expediting rate reviews. While the strategy has been credited with prompting companies like Farmers, The Travelers Companies, and Mercury to expand or maintain their California offerings, Kim has characterized the program as a concession that favors insurers over consumers.
Kim intends to scrutinize rate filings and approvals, aiming to ensure insurers pay claims promptly and increase transparency. She argues that the property/casualty industry has been profitable, citing a report suggesting the industry realized its first full-year underwriting gain in four years, with net income reaching $170 billion. Conversely, an analysis from the Insurance Information Institute, utilizing Best’s Market Share Reports, indicates the California homeowners market experienced a 10-year average combined ratio of 109.7% from 2014 to 2023, reflecting an underwriting loss.
Beyond reviewing existing policies, Kim has proposed a public program to cover wildfire risk for existing homes. Under this proposal, participation would be mandatory, with premiums determined by a combination of rebuilding costs and individual wildfire risk. Private insurers would continue to provide other homeowners coverages, while the public program would invest reserves in wildfire mitigation. This initiative would require approval from the governor and state lawmakers.
Industry representatives have expressed caution regarding potential changes to the current regulatory environment. Laura Curtis of the American Property Casualty Insurance Association emphasized the importance of maintaining recent market progress, warning that new mandates could risk reversing stability. Rex Frazier, president of the Personal Insurance Federation of California, advised against pre-judging rates before reviewing individual insurer filings.
For industry stakeholders, the transition signals a potential shift in regulatory philosophy. While current reforms have focused on stabilizing the market by incentivizing carrier participation, the incoming administration’s focus on affordability and public-sector intervention suggests a more aggressive regulatory approach that warrants close monitoring.
Why it matters
The shift in leadership suggests a potential pivot from market-stabilization incentives to a more consumer-focused regulatory environment, which could impact insurer participation and rate-setting processes in California.
FAQ
What is Jane Kim’s proposed public wildfire insurance program?
It is a mandatory program for existing homes where premiums are based on rebuilding costs and wildfire risk, with reserves invested in wildfire mitigation.
What is the Sustainable Insurance Strategy?
It is a program by outgoing commissioner Ricardo Lara that allows insurers to use catastrophe models and reinsurance costs in ratemaking to encourage them to write policies in high-risk areas.
What does the Insurance Information Institute data say about the California homeowners market?
The data indicates an average combined ratio of 109.7% from 2014 to 2023, which signifies an overall underwriting loss during that period.
Source: Insurance Journal. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone