Pennsylvania Court Limits Workers' Comp Offsets on COLAs
A 4-3 decision by Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court on November 9, 2026, has restricted how employers calculate workers' compensation offsets in relation to Social Security cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs). The ruling determines that employers are prohibited from increasing their offset amounts to capture a portion of federal inflation adjustments applied to an injured worker's Social Security retirement benefits.
The case involved an employee injured in 1997 while working for the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. When she began collecting Social Security retirement in 2017, the employer applied a 50% offset to her workers' compensation, reducing her weekly payments to $247.56. In the years following, the employer increased this offset by half of every COLA approved by Congress. The employee challenged this practice in 2023.
The court’s decision hinged on the interpretation of the term “benefits” within the state’s Workers’ Compensation Act. The majority concluded that because COLAs are funded entirely by the federal government to preserve purchasing power—rather than by employer contributions—allowing employers to claim a portion of these increases would effectively strip injured workers of their only inflation protection. The court noted that Pennsylvania does not otherwise adjust workers' compensation for inflation.
This ruling aligns Pennsylvania with courts in Colorado, Florida, Montana, and New Hampshire, which have previously rejected similar offset increases. Three judges dissented, arguing that the statute's language was broad enough to include all Social Security benefits, including COLAs. The dissent also highlighted potential inequities, noting that the majority's rule could lead to different offset amounts for workers who begin collecting Social Security at different times.
The decision applies to the employee’s 2023 challenge forward, meaning previous offsets that were not contested remain in place. For insurers and claims teams operating in Pennsylvania, the ruling serves as an immediate directive that COLA increases cannot be factored into offset calculations.
Why it matters
This ruling sets a precedent for Pennsylvania claims management, requiring insurers to cease adjusting workers' compensation offsets based on federal Social Security inflation adjustments.
FAQ
What was the core legal question in this case?
The court had to decide if the term “benefits” in the Workers’ Compensation Act included federally funded cost-of-living adjustments, or if the offset should be locked to the initial retirement amount.
Does this ruling apply retroactively to all past offsets?
No. The ruling applies from the employee’s 2023 challenge onward, and earlier offsets that were not contested remain in place.
Why did the court rule against allowing the offset increase?
The court reasoned that COLAs are funded by the federal government to maintain purchasing power, not by employers, and allowing the offset would deprive injured workers of their only inflation protection.
Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone