ACE Sues eBay to Block Cyberstalking Settlement Coverage
ACE Property & Casualty Insurance Company has initiated legal action to avoid covering a settlement related to a cyberstalking campaign orchestrated by former eBay executives. On November 12, 2026, the insurer filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, seeking a declaration that its $50 million commercial umbrella policy does not extend to the settlement reached with the publishers of the trade publication EcommerceBytes.
The underlying dispute involves a 2019 campaign in which eBay security staff targeted the publishers with various forms of harassment, including the delivery of live spiders, a funeral wreath, and a pig mask, alongside other intrusive tactics. While eBay and three former executives settled the lawsuit for nearly $48.7 million, with eBay paying $46.15 million, ACE contends that its policy does not cover these costs.
ACE’s legal argument centers on the assertion that the harassment was not an isolated incident but a deliberate strategy directed by senior eBay leadership. The insurer points to text messages between the company's former CEO, chief communications officer, and senior vice president of global operations as evidence of an intentional effort to silence critical reporting. ACE argues that these communications demonstrate that the conduct was expected and intended by the insured, triggering specific policy exclusions for bodily injury, property damage, and personal injury arising from criminal acts or intentional violations of others' rights.
Beyond the nature of the conduct, ACE raises procedural objections to the settlement. The insurer alleges that eBay finalized the agreement without providing the proposed terms for review or obtaining the necessary consent from ACE. Furthermore, the complaint notes that the settlement failed to distinguish between compensatory and punitive damages. Under California law, punitive damages are not insurable, and ACE argues that the lack of clarity regarding these figures complicates the coverage determination.
The case follows a 2024 deferred prosecution agreement between eBay and federal authorities, in which the company paid a $3 million penalty and admitted responsibility for the actions of its employees and officers. Seven members of the company's security team previously pleaded guilty to federal crimes related to the campaign.
This litigation serves as a critical test for how excess insurers evaluate claims involving executive misconduct and whether corporate admissions of responsibility can effectively void coverage for subsequent civil settlements.
Why it matters
This case highlights the limitations of umbrella policies when corporate leadership is directly involved in illegal conduct and underscores the importance of insurer consent in settlement negotiations.
FAQ
Why is ACE Property & Casualty refusing to cover the settlement?
ACE argues that the policy excludes coverage for intentional harm, criminal acts directed by the insured, and deliberate conduct, and that eBay settled the claim without the insurer's consent or review.
What was the total value of the settlement?
The settlement totaled nearly $48.7 million, with eBay contributing $46.15 million and individual executives paying the remainder.
What evidence does ACE cite regarding the intent of the harassment?
ACE points to text messages between former eBay senior executives that allegedly show a coordinated effort to silence the publishers of EcommerceBytes.
Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone