Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

France Cyberattacks: Insurance Gaps and Regulatory Delays

📅 2026-11-16 | 📰 Insurance Business UK
#cyber insurance #france #nis2 directive #cyber-physical risk #operational technology

France has emerged as a significant target for cyberattacks, with analysts identifying the country as one of the most heavily breached large jurisdictions in Europe. While some threat researchers note that ransomware groups have listed more victims in Germany and Italy, France’s recent incidents have been highly visible, involving state-linked sabotage, tax authority data breaches, and financial sector fraud.

The physical impact of these attacks has highlighted critical gaps in insurance coverage. In October, attackers compromised internet-connected refrigeration systems at approximately 700 commercial sites, primarily supermarkets. The breach caused stock spoilage and triggered at least 15 fires. Because the attack involved cyber-physical damage rather than data theft or ransom, brokers indicated that standard cyber policies typically exclude such losses. Furthermore, property insurance policies may fail to respond if their terms exclude losses resulting from cyber events. The Danish manufacturer of the affected controllers, Danfoss, noted that the systems were running outdated firmware, a vulnerability that had been previously identified by researchers.

Financial institutions have also faced significant exposure. In November, Crédit Mutuel Arkéa, a lender based in Brittany, reported that attackers accessed a service provider’s platform to initiate fraudulent transfers from the bank’s account. The bank estimated losses at approximately €100 million, though some funds were recovered. This incident underscores the complexity of determining which policy—cyber, crime, or financial institutions cover—should respond when losses occur via a third-party supplier.

Public sector breaches further complicate the landscape. In August, the French finance ministry confirmed that an intruder accessed data on 678,000 taxpayers, and earlier in the year, unauthorized access was disclosed regarding FICOBA, the national bank account register, which covers at least 1.2 million accounts. While these public sector losses are largely uninsured, they create downstream risks for insurers through increased identity fraud and phishing attempts.

Regulatory efforts to bolster security are currently behind schedule. France missed the October 17, 2024, deadline to transpose the EU’s NIS2 Directive into national law. As of July 8, 2026, the European Commission referred France, along with Spain, Ireland, and the Netherlands, to the EU Court of Justice. The French legislation, known as the loi Résilience, is intended to expand security and reporting duties to 15,000 organizations across 18 sectors, but it has faced significant delays.

For the insurance industry, these events demonstrate that connected operational technology and the speed at which clients patch firmware are now essential underwriting considerations. As cyber threats expand to include household appliances and routers, as warned by ENISA executive director Juhan Lepassaar, insurers must evaluate whether existing policies are equipped to handle the convergence of cyber and physical risk, particularly as clients integrate more connected devices into their operations.

Why it matters

The recent wave of cyber-physical attacks and supply chain breaches in France exposes critical ambiguities in policy wording, forcing underwriters to re-evaluate how cyber, property, and crime coverages interact when digital intrusions cause tangible, real-world damage.

FAQ

Why did insurance policies fail to cover the supermarket refrigeration attacks?
Brokers reported that standard cyber policies generally do not cover physical losses, and property policies may exclude damages caused by cyber events.

What is the status of the NIS2 Directive in France?
France missed the October 17, 2024, deadline to implement the directive, leading the European Commission to refer the country to the EU Court of Justice in July 2026.

How did the attack on Crédit Mutuel Arkéa occur?
Attackers gained access through a platform operated by one of the bank's service providers, allowing them to make fraudulent transfers from the bank's own account.

Source: Insurance Business UK. See the original source for full details.