West Virginia Court Upholds Denial of Taser Training Claim
An intermediate appeals court in West Virginia affirmed the denial of workers' compensation benefits for Raun Bowers, a security officer at Berkeley Medical Center, after he claimed a Taser shock during training caused back and leg injuries.
Bowers began employment on May 19, 2025, and participated in the Taser exercise eleven days later. He reported a five-second shock followed by back pain, leg weakness, dizziness and vision problems. A physician linked his back spasms and sciatic nerve issues to the electrical shock, while imaging showed pre-existing degenerative disc disease and lumbar abnormalities.
The employer’s claims administrator rejected his claim in July 2025, and the Workers’ Compensation Board of Review upheld that decision in April. The court noted Bowers had a history of chronic back pain, sciatica and lumbar radiculopathy dating to 2011, and a separate lawsuit from an April 2024 motor vehicle accident that also cited aggravation of a pre-existing condition.
Finding that Bowers did not prove a new injury separate from his longstanding back problems, the court deferred to the board’s assessment of his credibility and affirmed the denial of benefits.
Why it matters
The ruling highlights the evidentiary burden on claimants to distinguish new injuries from pre-existing conditions in workers' compensation cases.
FAQ
When did the Taser training incident occur?
Bowers participated in the training eleven days after starting work on May 19, 2025.
What injuries did Bowers claim resulted from the Taser shock?
He reported back pain, leg weakness, dizziness and vision problems.
Why did the court uphold the denial of benefits?
The court found Bowers failed to establish a new injury and deferred to the board’s finding that his testimony was not credible.
Source: Business Insurance. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone