M&A Deal Insurance Claims Hit Record High in 2025
Claims on representations and warranties (R&W) insurance for merger and acquisition (M&A) buyers reached a record in 2025, according to a briefing from Liberty Global Transaction Solutions (Liberty GTS). The insurer logged 176 claim notifications worldwide, a 26% increase over 2024, and expects the upward trend to continue into the first half of 2026, albeit at a slower pace.
The surge reflects both a rise in policy counts driven by heightened deal activity—especially in the lower-to-mid-market segment—and a genuine increase in notification frequency for newer years of account. Historically, roughly one in five R&W policies (20%) generate a claim over their lifecycle; Liberty GTS now projects that figure could climb to one in four (25%) for recent years of account, with the most pronounced jump seen in EMEA where notifications have risen well above historic levels since 2023.
Severity has risen alongside frequency. Average claim payments for policies from 2019-2022 hovered around $7 million, except for 2021 at $9 million. For claims on 2023 policies, the average payment grew to $9 million, and for 2024 policies it reached $13 million, though the 2024 figure is skewed by a single large loss. Payments of $10 million or more now represent about 75% of total dollars paid, up from roughly 68% at the end of 2024, and the insurer received more notifications of alleged losses of $10 million or more in the past 12 months than at any prior time.
Liberty GTS attributes part of the increase to the growth of “nil seller recourse” deals, where the seller bears no liability for breaches and the buyer relies solely on R&W insurance. The briefing also notes a shift in buyer behavior: post-closing reviews are increasingly used to identify claims, sometimes to renegotiate purchase price rather than solely to address buyer’s remorse. Additionally, more claims are being valued on a valuation-based methodology rather than a dollar-for-dollar loss, raising severity and adding complexity to adjustments.
Retention levels have fallen sharply since 2023, when deal activity collapsed. Retentions that once averaged 1.5% of enterprise value have largely disappeared, with most now below 0.5% and “tipping-to-nil” retentions common in several regions. Historically, about one in five primary-layer notifications results in a paid or reserved claim; this conversion rate may rise as retentions continue to decline. Excess policies show a lower conversion rate—under 5%—but when they do pay, the average payout is about $19.5 million, compared with roughly $7 million for primary-layer claims.
Extending coverage into the third year of ownership has proven significant. Fifteen percent of notifications from policies written in 2019-2022 occurred in Year 3, yet those notifications accounted for 33% of dollars paid and reserved, versus 43% in Year 1 and 22% in Year 2. Accounting and financial issues remain the top loss driver, responsible for 52% of dollars paid and reserved, followed by material contract and customer issues (14%), compliance with laws (12%), condition of asset issues (12%) and intellectual property issues (5%).
Why it matters
Rising claim frequency, severity, and lower retentions signal higher risk exposure for buyers and insurers in M&A transactions.
FAQ
How many R&W insurance claim notifications were recorded in 2025?
Liberty GTS received 176 notifications across all regions in 2025.
What is the projected claim notification rate for recent years of account?
The insurer projects the rate could rise to 1 in 4 policies (25%) for recent years of account.
Which region shows the most pronounced increase in notification frequency?
EMEA shows a notification frequency significantly above historic levels from 2023 onward.
What are the leading drivers of R&W losses?
Accounting and financial issues account for 52% of dollars paid and reserved, followed by material contract and customer issues (14%), compliance with laws (12%), condition of asset issues (12%) and intellectual property issues (5%).
Source: Risk & Insurance. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone