Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

California ALJ sues Insurance Dept over rate-increase approvals

📅 2026-11-11 | 📰 Insurance Business America
#california insurance #proposition 103 #rate increases #administrative law judge #regulatory oversight

A former chief administrative law judge of the California Department of Insurance has filed a lawsuit claiming the department sidestepped mandatory judicial oversight when approving rate-increase settlements for homeowners and auto insurers. Kristin Rosi, who served as the department’s top administrative judge from 2016 until her dismissal in 2025, lodged the suit in Alameda County Superior Court in late September 2026.

Rosi’s complaint centers on an October 2024 ruling in which she concluded that the department’s practice of approving rate increases through negotiated settlements violated Proposition 103, the 1988 ballot measure that requires prior approval and, when a consumer group requests a hearing, a public hearing before any increase can be ratified. She argued that even settlement-based approvals needed independent judicial sign-off to ensure fairness.

According to the filing, Commissioner Ricardo Lara and former special counsel Lucy Wang pressured Rosi to alter her ruling and dismissed her after she refused. Lara later partially vacated the decision, citing alleged legal errors identified by the Rate Enforcement Bureau. The lawsuit further alleges that Wang and senior officials restricted the Administrative Hearing Bureau’s case intake and that Lara emailed Rosi urging her to adopt a plan limiting judicial review to cases where a formal notice of hearing had already been issued.

Rosi also filed complaints with the California State Bar against Wang and three other officials, accusing them of improper ex parte communications with the department’s legal team on pending cases—an allegation that remains under investigation. Wang now works for a San Francisco law firm representing insurers and declined comment, citing representation by the attorney general’s office, which deferred to the Insurance Department.

The Administrative Hearing Bureau currently operates with a single judge, who in an August 2026 ruling noted staffing and resource constraints. Former commissioner Dave Jones, who appointed Rosi, described the allegations as “shocking and disturbing,” emphasizing the statutory wall that should separate the commissioner from the department’s final-decision processes.

The dispute has implications for California’s property market, where double-digit homeowners rate increases for major carriers were approved through the contested settlements. If the settlements indeed bypassed required judicial review, the rates paid by policyholders may not meet Proposition 103 standards. New Insurance Commissioner-elect Jane Kim has pledged to investigate the claims after taking office in January.

Why it matters

The case could reshape how California insurers obtain rate approvals, affecting premiums and market access for brokers and consumers.

FAQ

Who filed the lawsuit against the California Department of Insurance?
Former chief administrative law judge Kristin Rosi filed the suit in Alameda County Superior Court.

What does Proposition 103 require for insurance rate increases?
It requires prior department approval and a public hearing when a consumer group requests one before a rate can be approved.

What actions did Commissioner Lara take after Rosi’s ruling?
Lara partially vacated the ruling, citing legal errors, and later emailed Rosi urging her to adopt a plan limiting judicial review to cases with a formal notice of hearing.

What is the status of the State Bar complaints filed by Rosi?
The complaints remain pending and have not been made public.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.