Specialty Insurance Expertise and the Marine War Market
The marine war insurance class has dominated industry headlines throughout 2026, driven by shipping disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz following the conflict involving the US, Israel, and Iran that began in late February. While this activity has attracted significant capital to the market, HIVE Underwriters CEO Bruce Carman suggests that profitability in this sector requires more than just raising rates.
Carman emphasizes that marine war is a highly specialized field demanding deep historical understanding and nuanced risk assessment. He contrasts specialty insurance with commercial lines, noting that specialty risks are non-homogeneous and cannot be modeled as easily as standard commercial risks. For HIVE, success in specialty niches relies on combining reliable data with expert analysis. This approach is evident in the firm's space insurance division, where data scientists assist underwriters in evaluating the unique risks associated with individual satellite launches.
Regarding emerging classes, Carman notes that parametric and climate insurance are closely linked to the insurance-linked securities (ILS) market but remain outside HIVE’s current focus. Cyber insurance, however, is a growing area of interest, with its future development likely tied to the evolution of agentic AI. When evaluating long-tail classes like cyber or AI-related casualty, Carman stresses the necessity of robust data, including loss triangles and ratios, to effectively match third-party capital.
The capacity landscape for managing general agents (MGAs) is also shifting. Carman observes that carriers are becoming more selective as they enter a soft market cycle. While carriers are not necessarily providing more capacity to MGAs, there has been a notable movement of talent from major carriers into the entrepreneurial MGA sector. To secure capacity, MGAs must demonstrate a proven track record of outperformance rather than relying on polished presentations.
For brokers and capacity providers, Carman advocates for thorough due diligence when assessing an MGA’s specialist credentials. He warns against complacency, noting that past success does not guarantee future results. Ultimately, he argues that disciplined underwriting and genuine expertise remain the primary differentiators for profitability in specialized markets like marine war.
For insurance professionals, this highlights that rising premiums in volatile sectors like marine war do not automatically equate to sustainable profits. As capacity providers become more selective, the ability to demonstrate granular, data-backed underwriting expertise will be the deciding factor for MGAs seeking to secure support and maintain market relevance.
Why it matters
This article highlights how market volatility in marine war is forcing a shift toward data-driven underwriting and stricter MGA selection criteria.
FAQ
Why is marine war considered a difficult class to write profitably?
It is a highly specialized class that requires specific depth of knowledge regarding policy wordings and risk nuances, rather than simply increasing rates.
How does Bruce Carman view the current capacity environment for MGAs?
Carman believes carriers are becoming more selective as they enter a soft cycle, making it harder for newer entrants to secure capacity while established MGA relationships face increased scrutiny.
What is Carman's approach to evaluating an MGA's expertise?
He prioritizes experience backed by a track record of market outperformance and warns against relying on pitch decks that lack verifiable results.
Source: Insurance Business UK. See the original source for full details.
Scan with your phone
Scan with your phone