Smar NetworkSmar.inSmargrid.comNewsInsuranceRoomsGamesMeasurements

Insurance Daily News

Daily news and analysis on insurance industry trends, regulations, and market insights

Facebook Telegram
← Back to Insurance News

Operational Discipline Key to Insurance AI Success

๐Ÿ“… 2026-11-12 | ๐Ÿ“ฐ Insurance Business America
#insurance ai #operational discipline #insurtech #workflow automation #underwriting efficiency

Insurance carriers and managing general agents (MGAs) are increasingly adopting artificial intelligence, but industry experts suggest that the most successful organizations are not necessarily those with the most advanced technology. Instead, the firms pulling ahead are those that prioritized operational discipline before scaling their AI initiatives.

According to Michael Costonis of ReSource Pro, the effective deployment of AI requires foundational elements such as structured processes, accessible data, and clear decision-making rights. Without these prerequisites, AI implementation often results in fragmented, inconsistent usage across departments. Organizations lacking this discipline frequently see AI used only in isolated pockets, where individual employees utilize productivity hacks that are difficult to measure or replicate at scale.

A common pitfall for insurers is the decentralized adoption of AI tools. When AI solutions are pushed to individual users without a unified strategy, it leads to redundant workflows, mismatched data, and varying methods for achieving the same objectives. This lack of standardization makes it difficult for leadership to trust the results or maintain transparency regarding how those outcomes were generated. Furthermore, ineffective implementation often forces end-users to perform additional manual work, negating the efficiency gains the technology was intended to provide.

Costonis distinguishes between 'experimenters'โ€”who allow widespread, uncoordinated AI usageโ€”and organizations that take a deliberate, end-to-end approach. The latter group evaluates entire business functions to determine where processes can be standardized and where AI is the appropriate tool versus other techniques like deterministic code. True value, he notes, arises from a combination of human and machine interaction, often referred to as managed agentic services. This model involves humans refining workflows and providing feedback to the AI model to improve performance and adjust business structures.

For leaders assessing their own AI maturity, the litmus test lies in the full end-to-end workflow. If an AI output requires significant manual intervention from an underwriter or supervisor, the value of the automation is undermined. Successful implementation requires clear guardrails, transparency, and an understanding of where value is created versus where it is destroyed within the process.

For insurance executives, this highlights that the primary hurdle to AI ROI is often organizational process rather than the software itself; firms should audit their end-to-end workflows for standardization before investing further in AI tools.

Why it matters

This article highlights that operational process maturity is a prerequisite for successful AI integration, cautioning insurers against focusing solely on the technology itself.

FAQ

What is the main difference between 'experimenters' and successful AI adopters in insurance?
Experimenters use AI in isolated pockets without a unified strategy, whereas successful adopters take a deliberate, end-to-end approach that standardizes processes and data before scaling.

What are 'managed agentic services'?
These are services where humans work alongside machines to refine workflows, provide feedback to the AI model, and modify procedures to improve performance.

What is a key indicator that an AI implementation is failing to deliver value?
Value is destroyed when an AI output requires significant manual evaluation by an underwriter or supervisor, effectively negating the efficiency gains of the automation.

Source: Insurance Business America. See the original source for full details.